Constant Change
When Benjamin Franklin wrote “in this world nothing can be said to be certain, except death and taxes” in 1789 he missed something. He feared that despite the “promise of permanency” for the new Constitution its future was not certain. And while in today’s tumultuous political circumstances, we may often fear for the health of the Constitution, I will leave that for another conversation. I am thinking that Franklin did not acknowledge the realization that Heraclitus had said somewhere around 500 BCE that the only constant in life is change. Fortunately for us, most changes, even the really big ones, have not, to date brought down the Constitution. May that long continue to be the case.
Two headlines from articles in recently culled 1983 issues of California Lawyer triggered these thoughts.
October “Goodbye yellow pads, hello computers: Times are changing, and law firms that don’t computerize soon will be at a disadvantage”
November “How to be a powerful dictator: Understand the differences between spoken and written language and use a full outline”
Early computer-based legal research was really expensive and really finicky about how queries were phrased. The data had to run across the country on phone lines to and from huge mainframe computers.
While it is much more pleasant to read the text of a case from a printed page, it is much easier to access a wide range of information from one place today. Sites like LexisNexis and Westlaw, mean online research for legal professionals can replace most print libraries, and once you know what case you are seeking, anyone can enter it into a search engine like Google and read the opinion. Yes, computers are necessary for research today and give much broader access to information.
November’s headline is not a political statement. It harks back to when instead of handwriting the draft of a letter or a report it would be spoken into a Dictaphone and transcribed by a secretary. Faster, easier, but as the headline implies, not always accurate or truly efficient if you don’t know exactly what you need to say. I can recall some, um, “creative” selections of words when the typist heard an unfamiliar term. Are such errors amusing? Often. A waste of time? Probably. Oh, and don’t forget to state the punctuation. You don’t think vocal intonation will place commas, periods, and semicolons where you want them, do you? But today, just type your own draft and you can move things around easily if your outline wasn’t the best. Perhaps the voice recording on smart phones sneaks into this niche a bit, but computers are the larger and earlier changemaker.
Word processing was then a specialized secretarial job requiring a big machine, not the regular electric typewriter most secretaries used (though some secretaries did have those exciting, early IBM machines that held a few lines in memory!!!) Today anyone can process all the words they want to! Everyone has the power to process words at their fingertips, just as I am now. Yes, computers have revolutionized document creation and management. Jobs must have been lost to computers.
It was irresistible, so, law firms adopted personal computers and then laptops, and research by internet. Budgets went for subscriptions to online reference materials, instead of all those
someday-to-be-dusty tomes, nice as they are to hold. The Dictaphone replaced the steno pool, and word-processors saved typists a whole lot of retyping, and copiers made carbon paper unused; we continue to need to learn an ever-accelerating onrush of changes.
Whether you were a lawyer, a paralegal or a typist, these were big changes in how many people worked. This is a good reminder of Heraclitus’s maxim.
And today our challenge in all fields is AI, artificial intelligence. Whether we like it or not, it is
here, so how do we work with it? Where can it help us? Where can we trust it? Who will it
replace? What does it get right and what does it just.. not.. get? A few years ago, I heard a
speaker say that when you ask AI a question what you get back is an output, not an answer, so you need to check what it says rather than adopting it blindly. It could follow patterns and
rapidly sort large amounts of data, but it was also prone to hallucinations and did not
understand, or choose to follow, many ethical rules. On the other hand, AI, and there are so
many versions, is learning at a terrifying speed.
A few years ago, AI could not be trusted to do arithmetic problems correctly and now it is
solving the “unsolvable” math problems. Because the answers to mathematics problems are
verifiable, it can be a good benchmark for the progress of an AI system. [from excerpts by Sam Altman and Sébastien Bubeck in the On Point presentation noted below.]
There is a fascinating discussion of what the incredible speed at which AI systems are becoming “smarter” could mean, both for mathematicians and their jobs, and more largely, for the future of human thinking [I kid you not.] in the On Point episode on October 13, 2026, titled “AI is steamrolling through math. Why does that matter?” [listen or read a transcript]
Mathematician Hugo Duminil-Copin, of the University of Geneva, a winner of the prestigious
Fields Medal, who finds that with the solution of the Navier-Stokes equation by AI all of his
research projects have been gutted. He states “We are the day after tomorrow. We need to
rethink our way of thinking.” Now what? Duminil-Copin also sees math not only as the
language and tool for science, but also as a study of humans and how they think.
Another of Meghna Chakrabarti’s guests was Professor Steven Strogatz, a professor of Public
Understanding of Science and Mathematics at Cornell. [Great title. Great concept. Much
needed.] He notes, agreeing with Duminil-Copin that math is the science of art and abstraction, and as such, “it is also an expression of human creativity, of the process of thinking and working hard to create new ways of seeing and understanding the world. And in that way, I think it's like art, writing, music-making, even trying to think just creatively about how to solve everyday problems in our own lives.” (emphasis added) We cannot lose our ability to think deeply in these complicated times.
Major problems and breakthroughs in math and science tend to come over long periods of time and may require the thinker to think outside the box...Maybe the earth is not the center of the universe...and when scientists try to do things that are really hard (with the knowledge up to their date) they accomplish amazing things that often have additional, unplanned amazing spin-offs.
My son has told me of discussing the use of AI with job candidates. He would ask what they
would do next if AI gave an unacceptable response. If they would just go back and try AI again, he ruled them out. They had to indicate a willingness to think for themselves as well as an ability to use contemporary tools. If we rely too much on AI, we won’t be thinking hard and creatively. We may miss untold discoveries, or just better ways to meet today’s challenges.
I cannot truly fit that hour into these few paragraphs. It is a fun listen and will make you think.
And isn’t that a good thing?

